Madonna made such specificity cool long before it was the standard. Watching her career progress from the early 1980s and into the late 1990s, we get a front-row seat into the evolution of a person—an almost-Freudian unfurling during which a woman uncovers new things about herself and her life and the vast possibilities of the world around her in real time. Back in the late ’80s and early ’90s, we saw Madonna reckon with her strict Catholic upbringing in Michigan on songs like “Papa Don’t Preach” and “Like a Prayer.” We then saw her having a sexual awakening on “Justify My Love” and the entirety of the Erotica album. We also saw her settle into a calmer and more mature sensuality on Bedtime Stories, in which she broke the fourth wall with “Human Nature” to harangue puritanical critics for giving her such a hard time throughout it all.
Photo: Getty Images
At times, her seeking has led to backlash, namely after the kink-positive Sex book and a 2003 album, American Life, which skewered consumerism and the Bush administration (where’s the lie?). But at her best, there’s no one with more clarity of vision than Madonna when she has a particular perspective to share. With the remarkable Ray of Light, we find Madonna at her most ambitious, not just musically, but personally and spiritually too. On it, she turned to the progressive sound of European techno to explore fresh interests in yoga and mysticism, all while detailing what new motherhood meant to her as a woman. It is the ur-form of pop album as philosophical treatise, the apogee of a creative life spent searching for material and meaning that can be transmuted through melodies and lyrics.
All in all, I’d argue that every time Rodrigo hands out birth control at her concerts, Charli turns inward to examine the relationship between self-esteem, sex, and drugs in her own life, Sabrina Carpenter skewers male immaturity and demands more from the opposite sex, or Chappell Roan claims the gay club as a space of self-invention and freedom, there is more than a hint of Madonna in the act. The only other modern woman in pop who could be said to wield this kind of cultural influence is, of course, Beyoncé Knowles, who has continually reinvented herself and created a new political and personal mythology with each album. But even Beyoncé has acknowledged the blueprint of “Queen Mother Madonna,” as she’s called on the “Break My Soul” remix—a track that cleverly blends the Renaissance single with Madonna’s “Vogue.”
And so, it’s hard to know what we want from a new Madonna album in 2026—what left is there to do? To say? Confessions II is notably self-referential, presented as a follow-up to her wonderful 2005 album Confessions on a Dance Floor, which gave us “Hung Up” and “Sorry.”
But then another thought comes to mind: barring the critics, the naysayers, and the schadenfreude-seekers, Madonna should do whatever it is Madonna wants to do. That may just be the ultimate lesson of her career—that the only path worth taking is the one that feels true to yourself at any given moment in time, whether the rest of us understand it or not. And if this era doesn’t land, she can do what she has always done: regroup, reinvent, dust herself off, and become someone new. We’ll be lucky to get to watch.
